| 1996 | |
| Kevin Crane | Boston Collge |
| Nick Gerhardt | Albion College |
| Scot Naz | Central Michigan University |
| Pat Gibson | Northern Michigan University |
| 1997 | |
| Jeff Konfara | Hope College |
| Riky Styes | Kalamazoo College |
| Frank Stanford | Saginaw Valley University |
| 1998 | |
| Eric Sage | Saginaw Valley University |
| Luciano Gonzales | Saginaw Valley University |
| 1999 | |
| James King | Central Michigan University |
| Lorenzo Parker | Vanderbilt University |
| Cody Cargill | Yale University |
| Chris Payton | Western Michigan University |
| Rob Pisha | Marrietta College |
| Larry Bigger | Eastern Michigan University |
| Jason Martin | Central Michigan University |
| 2000 | |
| Tony Henry | Grand Valley State University |
| Tim King | Grand Rapids Community College |
| Ryan Ziem | Albion |
| Brent Erwin | Hillsdale |
| Adam Michaud | Grand Valley State University |
| Jason Apostolopoulos | Albion College |
| Mike Little | Grand Valley State University |
| Mick Michniacki | Detroit Fury |
| Chris Hoenle | Defiance College |
| 2001 | |
| Mike Pisha | Albion College |
| Mike Larges | Alma College |
| Steve Bell | Grand Rapids College |
| Barima Opong-Owusu | University of Michigan |
| Brandon Burtis | Saginaw Valley university |
| 2002 | |
| Bryan Phillips | Northwood University |
| Steve Darby | Northern Michigan University |
| John Sowders | Northern Michigan University |
| Steve VanNotwick | Olivet College |
| Mark Guy | Adrian College |
| 2003 | |
| Luis Fonseca | Michigan State University |
| Greg Hay | University of Toledo |